✨ Feature Suggestion | Changelog to the website #2079

New Issue

2020-10-06T12:10:08Z

3k2 commented

2020-10-06 12:10:08 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

It's very hard to find information why certain service/browser addon etc has been removed or added. Like for example couple of months ago I visited Privacytools.io to check if there has been any new browser recommendations. Well to my surprise Cookie Auto Delete was removed I tried to search the website for some changelog or blog post why this was the case but couldn't find any answer why all sudden it wasn't recommended to use anymore. But it would appear for Android it is recommended.

That's why I'd suggest adding some sort of changelog or blog post where people can easily find information why certain changes has been made.

It's very hard to find information why certain service/browser addon etc has been removed or added. Like for example couple of months ago I visited Privacytools.io to check if there has been any new browser recommendations. Well to my surprise Cookie Auto Delete was removed I tried to search the website for some changelog or blog post why this was the case but couldn't find any answer why all sudden it wasn't recommended to use anymore. But it would appear for Android it is recommended. That's why I'd suggest adding some sort of changelog or blog post where people can easily find information why certain changes has been made.

gary-host-laptop commented

2020-10-06 14:37:52 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

I've been thinking about this, too, it would be a great idea, and the only thing you would have to do is describe the change the link to their respective Github issues.

nitrohorse commented

2020-10-06 16:33:25 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

One option that comes to mind that works across all GitHub repos is subscribing to the commit (change) history via RSS: https://github.com/privacytools/privacytools.io/commits/master.atom (add “.atom” to the URL)

👍 2 😕 1

blacklight447 commented

2020-10-08 08:38:48 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

@freddy-m Was interested in writing a "this month in privacytools" news letter, maybe this could work out?

gary-host-laptop commented

2020-10-08 19:10:21 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

@blacklight447-ptio I think although that's better than nothing, it's not something so good since it's not so organised as a changelog, and also has a lot more of information than what you might need. Also with a changelog you can browse what was removed five years ago and why in some sort of list, whereas with blog posts you would have to dig up a lot of posts before reaching what you're interested in.

blacklight447 commented

2020-10-08 19:24:10 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

Tbh, for something that goes back five years, we already have our commit log, so people who really want to dig in can always find it there.

privacytoolsIO commented

2020-10-08 23:27:34 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

Good idea. It could be done very simple with a text based changelog, manually. We explain in one short sentence what has been changed / removed / added and link to the github discussion. It might be even worth it to hide this behind a "notification bell" in the header menu with the latest 10 items and with a "more..." link, the menu unfolds when you click on it. It's nowhere near a complete changelog, only items should be added that affect content (added / removed / edited)

👍 1

lynn-stephenson commented

2020-10-09 00:39:44 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

A good idea might be to "release" PT with semantic versioning.

Declaring any additions, removals, changes, etc.

A good idea might be to "release" PT with semantic versioning. Declaring any additions, removals, changes, etc.

gary-host-laptop commented

2020-10-09 13:00:31 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

Tbh, for something that goes back five years, we already have our commit log, so people who really want to dig in can always find it there.

It was just an example, because if you create the changelog, after 5 years of it being active, you can still browse it in a comfortable manner.

A good idea might be to "release" PT with semantic versioning.

Declaring any additions, removals, changes, etc.

I would still prefer the changelog, but that's me.

> Tbh, for something that goes back five years, we already have our commit log, so people who really want to dig in can always find it there. It was just an example, because if you create the changelog, after 5 years of it being active, you can still browse it in a comfortable manner. > A good idea might be to "release" PT with semantic versioning. > > Declaring any additions, removals, changes, etc. I would still prefer the changelog, but that's me.

oXyiGYJ commented

2020-11-07 02:28:40 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

Issue #2104 talks about this as well.

I agree. I know when I first joined I saw sections being removed, and wasn't fully sure where to find information on why that happened. Maybe a "recently removed" section on the site showing X amount of previously removed recommendations with a brief summary as to why would be good. This could also go in line with Lynn's recommendation.

Open for discussion, and maybe even putting in some PRs frequently for that.

Issue #2104 talks about this as well. I agree. I know when I first joined I saw sections being removed, and wasn't fully sure where to find information on why that happened. Maybe a "recently removed" section on the site showing X amount of previously removed recommendations with a brief summary as to why would be good. This could also go in line with Lynn's recommendation. Open for discussion, and maybe even putting in some PRs frequently for that.

lynn-stephenson commented

2020-11-18 07:44:27 +00:00

(Migrated from github.com)

This issue is being closed (more like moved), as #2104 is more generic. Discussion should continue there.

This repo is archived. You cannot comment on issues.