const ComparisonTable = () => {
const [selectedFeature, setSelectedFeature] = React.useState(null);
const messengers = [
{
name: "SecureBit.chat",
logo:
,
type: "P2P WebRTC",
version: "Latest",
color: "orange",
},
{
name: "Signal",
logo: (
),
type: "Centralized",
version: "Latest",
color: "blue",
},
{
name: "Threema",
logo: (
),
type: "Centralized",
version: "Latest",
color: "green",
},
{
name: "Session",
logo: (
),
type: "Onion Network",
version: "Latest",
color: "cyan",
},
];
const features = [
{
name: "Security Architecture",
lockbit: { status: "trophy", detail: "18-layer military-grade defense system with complete ASN.1 validation" },
signal: { status: "check", detail: "Signal Protocol with double ratchet" },
threema: { status: "check", detail: "Standard security implementation" },
session: { status: "check", detail: "Modified Signal Protocol + Onion routing" },
},
{
name: "Cryptography",
lockbit: { status: "trophy", detail: "ECDH P-384 + AES-GCM 256 + ECDSA P-384" },
signal: { status: "check", detail: "Signal Protocol + Double Ratchet" },
threema: { status: "check", detail: "NaCl + XSalsa20 + Poly1305" },
session: { status: "check", detail: "Modified Signal Protocol" },
},
{
name: "Perfect Forward Secrecy",
lockbit: { status: "trophy", detail: "Auto rotation every 5 minutes or 100 messages" },
signal: { status: "check", detail: "Double Ratchet algorithm" },
threema: { status: "warning", detail: "Partial (group chats)" },
session: { status: "check", detail: "Session Ratchet algorithm" },
},
{
name: "Architecture",
lockbit: { status: "trophy", detail: "Pure P2P WebRTC without servers" },
signal: { status: "times", detail: "Centralized Signal servers" },
threema: { status: "times", detail: "Threema servers in Switzerland" },
session: { status: "warning", detail: "Onion routing via network nodes" },
},
{
name: "Registration Anonymity",
lockbit: { status: "trophy", detail: "No registration required, instant anonymous channels" },
signal: { status: "times", detail: "Phone number required" },
threema: { status: "check", detail: "ID generated locally" },
session: { status: "check", detail: "Random session ID" },
},
{
name: "Payment Integration",
lockbit: { status: "trophy", detail: "Lightning Network satoshis per session + WebLN" },
signal: { status: "times", detail: "No payment system" },
threema: { status: "times", detail: "No payment system" },
session: { status: "times", detail: "No payment system" },
},
{
name: "Metadata Protection",
lockbit: { status: "trophy", detail: "Full metadata encryption + traffic obfuscation" },
signal: { status: "warning", detail: "Sealed Sender (partial)" },
threema: { status: "warning", detail: "Minimal metadata" },
session: { status: "check", detail: "Onion routing hides metadata" },
},
{
name: "Traffic Obfuscation",
lockbit: { status: "trophy", detail: "Fake traffic + pattern masking + packet padding" },
signal: { status: "times", detail: "No traffic obfuscation" },
threema: { status: "times", detail: "No traffic obfuscation" },
session: { status: "check", detail: "Onion routing provides obfuscation" },
},
{
name: "Open Source",
lockbit: { status: "trophy", detail: "100% open + auditable + MIT license" },
signal: { status: "check", detail: "Fully open" },
threema: { status: "warning", detail: "Only clients open" },
session: { status: "check", detail: "Fully open" },
},
{
name: "MITM Protection",
lockbit: { status: "trophy", detail: "Out-of-band verification + mutual auth + ECDSA" },
signal: { status: "check", detail: "Safety numbers verification" },
threema: { status: "check", detail: "QR code scanning" },
session: { status: "warning", detail: "Basic key verification" },
},
{
name: "Economic Model",
lockbit: { status: "trophy", detail: "Sustainable pay-per-session model" },
signal: { status: "warning", detail: "Donations and grants dependency" },
threema: { status: "check", detail: "One-time app purchase" },
session: { status: "warning", detail: "Donations dependency" },
},
{
name: "Censorship Resistance",
lockbit: { status: "trophy", detail: "Impossible to block P2P + no servers to target" },
signal: { status: "warning", detail: "Blocked in authoritarian countries" },
threema: { status: "warning", detail: "May be blocked" },
session: { status: "check", detail: "Onion routing bypasses blocks" },
},
{
name: "Data Storage",
lockbit: { status: "trophy", detail: "Zero data storage - only in browser memory" },
signal: { status: "warning", detail: "Local database storage" },
threema: { status: "warning", detail: "Local + optional backup" },
session: { status: "warning", detail: "Local database storage" },
},
{
name: "Key Security",
lockbit: { status: "trophy", detail: "Non-extractable keys + hardware protection" },
signal: { status: "check", detail: "Secure key storage" },
threema: { status: "check", detail: "Local key storage" },
session: { status: "check", detail: "Secure key storage" },
},
{
name: "Post-Quantum Roadmap",
lockbit: { status: "check", detail: "Planned v5.0 - CRYSTALS-Kyber/Dilithium" },
signal: { status: "warning", detail: "PQXDH in development" },
threema: { status: "times", detail: "Not announced" },
session: { status: "times", detail: "Not announced" },
},
];
const getStatusIcon = (status) => {
const statusMap = {
"trophy": { icon: "fa-trophy", color: "accent-orange" },
"check": { icon: "fa-check", color: "text-green-300" },
"warning": { icon: "fa-exclamation-triangle", color: "text-yellow-300" },
"times": { icon: "fa-times", color: "text-red-300" },
};
return statusMap[status] || { icon: "fa-question", color: "text-gray-400" };
};
const toggleFeatureDetail = (index) => {
setSelectedFeature(selectedFeature === index ? null : index);
};
return (
{/* Title */}
Enhanced Security Edition Comparison
Enhanced Security Edition vs leading secure messengers
{/* Table container */}
{/* Mobile Alert */}
Rotate your device horizontally for better viewing
{/* Table */}
{/* Table Header */}
|
Security Criterion
|
{messengers.map((messenger, index) => (
{messenger.logo}
{messenger.name}
{messenger.type}
{messenger.version}
|
))}
{/* Table body */}
{features.map((feature, featureIndex) => (
toggleFeatureDetail(featureIndex)}
>
|
{feature.name}
|
|
|
|
|
{/* Details */}
{selectedFeature === featureIndex && (
| Technical Details: |
{feature.lockbit.detail}
|
{feature.signal.detail}
|
{feature.threema.detail}
|
{feature.session.detail}
|
)}
))}
{/* Legend */}
Category Leader
Excellent
Partial/Limited
Not Available
);
};
window.ComparisonTable = ComparisonTable;